Is Polygamy Legal? (Legal Implications of Polygamy)

Polygamy is a term that is used to describe when a person has more than one spouse. This type of marriage is not recognized by the law in most countries, but there are some exceptions. In this blog post, we will explore the legality of polygamy and discuss some of the pros and cons of this type of marriage.

What is Polygamy?

Polygamy is defined as having more than one wife or husband at the same time. In some cultures, polygamy is practiced as a form of polygyny, where a man has multiple wives. In others, it may be practiced as polyandry, where a woman has multiple husbands.

While some states permit polygamous marriages entered into outside of their jurisdiction (usually for religious reasons), polygamy is illegal throughout the U.S. 

Polygamous marriages are sometimes referred to as “plural marriages.” A man who practices polygamy is known as a “polygynist,” and a woman who practices polygamy is known as a “polygyny.”

Polygamy is sometimes practiced in cultures that condone multiple wives for a single man. In these cultures, women do not have the same social status, legal rights, or economic independence as they do in the U.S. Polygamous marriages are usually entered into by men of high status and wealth; the number of wives a man can afford to maintain often determines his social standing.

Is Polygamy Legal?

The answer to this question depends on the country that you are asking. In some countries, polygamy is illegal. This means that if you are married to more than one person, your marriage will not be recognized by the government. 

In some other countries, polygamy is legal. For example, in some Muslim countries, polygamy is legal for men but not for women. 

In other countries, like the United States, polygamy is not specifically outlawed, but it is not recognized by the government either.

In the United States, polygamy is illegal in all fifty states. However, some states have what is known as a “common law marriage” which allows for a husband and wife to live together and be considered married even if they are not legally married. This type of arrangement is often used by polygamous couples who wish to avoid being charged with bigamy or polygamy.

Arguments For and Against of Polygamy (Advantages and Disadvantages of Polygamy)

Some argue that polygamy is a violation of human rights, while others believe that it can be empowering for women. Here are some pros and cons of polygamy:

PROS:

  • Polygamy can provide financial stability for families. In many cases, the husband is able to support multiple wives and children.
  • Polygamy can offer emotional support and companionship for women. In some cultures, women are expected to live with their husband’s family after marriage. This can be isolating for women who do not have close relationships with their in-laws.
  • Polygamy can give couples more freedom to have relationships with other people. In monogamous relationships, couples may feel jealous if their partner has a close relationship with someone else. In a polygamous relationship, this is not an issue.

CONS:

  • Polygamy can lead to inequality between wives. The first wife in a polygamous marriage often has more power and status than the subsequent wives. This can create tension and conflict within the family.
  • Polygamy can be emotionally demanding for women. In some cultures, polygamy is seen as a way to increase a man’s social status. This can put pressure on women to bear children and care for their families.
  • Polygamy can be harmful to children. In some cases, children may be neglected or abused in polygamous families. They may also have difficulty forming close relationships with their siblings.

Overall, there are both pros and cons to polygamy. What matters most is how the practice is carried out within a particular culture or community. When polygamy is based on equality and respect, it can be a positive force for families and relationships. However, when it leads to inequality and conflict, it can be damaging for all involved.

Family Law and  Polygamy

In the United States, polygamy is not recognized as a legal marriage. It is considered bigamy, which is a felony offense punishable by up to five years in prison.

The practice of polygamy is relatively rare in the U.S., but there are an estimated 30,000 to 50,000 people who live in polygamous households across the country. Most of these families belong to Mormon fundamentalist groups that believe in plural marriage as a religious principle.

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS) abandoned the practice of polygamy in 1890 as a condition of Utah’s statehood. However, there are still some Mormon polygamist groups that exist today, such as the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (FLDS).

Polygamous marriages are not recognized by the U.S. government and are therefore not eligible for any federal benefits or protections. This means that if a man is married to multiple wives, only one of those marriages will be recognized for purposes of things like taxes, insurance, social security, and inheritance.

While polygamy is illegal in the U.S., there are some areas where it is tolerated or even encouraged. For example, in some Native American tribes, polygamy is practiced as a way of preserving their culture and traditions.

Bigamy

The act of marrying one person while already married to another is bigamy, and it is illegal in the United States. 

If a person marries someone while still legally married to another, the second marriage is not valid. Bigamy laws in the U.S. are based on the premise that monogamy better protects women’s rights, children’s welfare, and social stability.

So why is polygamy illegal?

The answer lies in the history of monogamy. Historically, monogamy was seen as a way to prevent men from leaving their pregnant wives and abandoning their children. In addition, monogamy was seen as a way to prevent men from hoarding resources and using them to buy multiple wives.

Today, polygamy is illegal because it is seen as a form of bigamy. Bigamy is the crime of marrying one person while already married to another. It is punishable by law in many countries, including the United States.

Bigamy as a Ground for Annullment

In the United States, bigamy is a ground for annulment. An annulment is a legal procedure that cancels a marriage. Bigamy is grounds for an annulment because it violates public policy.

Public policy is based on the belief that monogamous marriage is in the best interest of society. It promotes stability and protects women’s rights, children’s welfare, and social order. Polygamous marriages are not recognized by law because they are contrary to public policy.

Annulling a polygamous marriage is different from getting a divorce. A divorce ends a valid marriage; an annulment says the marriage was never valid in the first place. If you are in a polygamous relationship, you can get a divorce from your first spouse, but you will not be able to marry your second spouse until the divorce is final.

There are some exceptions to the bigamy laws in the United States. If you move to another country that allows polygamy, you may be able to legally marry more than one person. But if you move back to the United States, you will not be considered married under U.S. law.

Polygamy is also allowed in some religious ceremonies. For example, some Native American tribes allow their members to practice polygamy as part of their religion. But even in these cases, the marriages are not recognized by state or federal law.

So while there are some exceptions, generally speaking, polygamy is illegal in the United States. It is seen as a form of bigamy and goes against public policy. If you are considering entering into a polygamous relationship, you should consult with an attorney to understand your legal rights and risks.

Criminal Sanctions on Polygamy

While polygamy is not currently illegal in the United States, there are a number of states that have laws prohibiting the practice. These laws vary from state to state, but typically make it a crime to live with or marry more than one person at a time. In some states, polygamous marriages are void and bigamous marriages are felonies punishable by prison sentences.

In Utah, where the practice of polygamy was once common among Mormon settlers, polygamous marriages are no longer recognized by the state and bigamy is a third-degree felony. However, Utah’s law enforcement has been known to turn a blind eye to plural families as long as there are no reports of abuse or fraud.

In Arizona, both polygamy and bigamy are felonies punishable by up to five years in prison. In Arizona, a person can be charged with polygamy even if he or she is not married to more than one person at the same time.

In New Jersey, polygamy is not specifically illegal but bigamy is a third-degree crime. Bigamy in New Jersey is defined as marrying someone while still legally married to someone else. It is also a crime to live with or cohabitate with more than one partner at a time.

While polygamy is not currently illegal in Canada, there are some restrictions on the practice. For example, polygamous marriages entered into outside of Canada are not recognized by the government and bigamy is a criminal offense. Additionally, Canadian immigration law prohibits polygamous marriages from being used to gain entry into the country.

In the United Kingdom, polygamy is not illegal but bigamy is a crime. Bigamy in the UK is defined as marrying someone while already legally married to someone else or entering into a polygamous marriage. It is also a crime to live with or cohabitate with more than one partner at a time.

While there are no federal laws prohibiting polygamy in the United States, it is important to note that the practice is against the law in many states. If you are considering entering into a polygamous relationship, it is important to consult an attorney to ensure that you are not breaking any laws

Additionally, polygamy can have negative consequences for your immigration status if you are not a US citizen. If you are considering entering into a polygamous marriage, it is important to seek legal counsel to ensure that you are not putting your immigration status at risk.

Polygamy and Succession Law

Polygamy is the practice of having more than one spouse. While it is illegal in many countries, there are some places where it is still practiced. In some cases, polygamy can be a way to keep property and assets within a family.

When it comes to succession law, things can get complicated. If someone dies without a will, their assets will be distributed according to the laws of intestate succession. This means that all of the deceased person’s assets will go to their spouse or next of kin. However, if the deceased person was practicing polygamy, things can get tricky.

In some cases, the surviving spouses may not be able to inherit anything because they were not married to the deceased person under civil law. This can create a problem when it comes to distributing the deceased person’s assets.

Wills and Trusts in Polygamous Succession

When it comes to succession law, things can get complicated. If someone dies without a will, their assets will be distributed according to the laws of intestate succession. This means that all of the deceased person’s assets will go to their spouse or next of kin. However, if the deceased person was practicing polygamy, things can get tricky.

In some cases, the surviving spouses may not be able to inherit anything because they were not married to the deceased person under civil law. This can create a problem when it comes to distributing the deceased person’s assets.

One way to avoid this problem is for people in polygamous relationships to create wills and trusts. By doing this, they can specify how they want their assets to be distributed. This can help to ensure that all of the people they want to inherit from them are able to do so.

It is important to consult with an experienced lawyer when creating a will or trust. They can help you to make sure that everything is set up correctly and that all of your wishes are carried out. Polygamy may not be legal in all countries, but that doesn’t mean that it isn’t practiced. If you are in a polygamous relationship, it is important to understand how succession law works and how you can protect your assets. Wills and trusts can be a helpful tool in this process.

Constitutional Issues on Polygamy

The legality of polygamy varies from country to country. In some countries, like the United States, polygamy is illegal. In others, like many countries in Africa and Asia, it is legal.

There are a number of constitutional issues that arise from polygamy. One issue is whether polygamous marriages are valid under the Constitution. Another issue is whether laws prohibiting polygamy violate the freedom of religion.

In the United States, polygamy is not recognized as a legal marriage. The Supreme Court has upheld laws prohibiting polygamy on several occasions. In 1878, in Reynolds v. United States, the Court ruled that polygamy was not protected by the First Amendment’s guarantee of freedom of religion.

In 2003, in Lawrence v. Texas, the Court struck down a state law criminalizing homosexual sodomy. Some have argued that this decision could be used to argue that laws against polygamy are also unconstitutional. However, the Court has not yet had an opportunity to rule on this issue directly.

in Obergefell v. Hodges,  the Court held that the right to marry is a fundamental right guaranteed by the Constitution. This decision could be used to argue that laws against polygamy are unconstitutional. However, the Court has not yet had an opportunity to rule on this issue directly.

Another constitutional issue that arises from polygamy is whether laws against it violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The Equal Protection Clause prohibits states from denying any person the equal protection of the laws.

Some have argued that laws against polygamy discriminate against men, because they are more likely to be polygamous than women. Others have argued that laws against polygamy do not discriminate against anyone, because both men and women can engage in monogamous relationships.

It is clear that there are constitutional issues with polygamy. Whether it is legal or not depends on the interpretation of the Constitution. It is likely that the Supreme Court will eventually have to decide these issues definitively. Until then, the legality of polygamy remains in question.

The constitutionality of polygamy is an issue that is likely to continue to be debated in the United States for many years to come.

Conclusion

So, is polygamy legal or not? The answer is complicated. While there are no federal laws outlawing the practice, there are some states that have outlawed it. Additionally, the Supreme Court has ruled against it in past cases. 

However, the current landscape of the country may be changing soon. With more and more people pushing for greater acceptance of alternative lifestyles, it’s possible that polygamy could become more accepted in the future. Only time will tell.

Thanks for reading!

Leave a Comment